W. H. Auden
He was my North, my South, my East and West,
My working week and my Sunday rest,
My noon, my midnight, my talk, my song;
I thought that love would last forever: I was wrong.
******
Over more than 3 decades of living together we built ourselves a special world-for-two, my husband and I. Our own private paradise became all the better after we retired from the hustle and bustle of high pressure careers.
We were so sure PC was going to make it, that the cord blood transplant would be a success and we would go back home without the sword of CLL hanging over our heads. Failure was not an option for either of us – so much so that we never made any contingency plans, never took the time to say all the things we had to say, our just-in-case goodbyes. Then suddenly it was too late to say anything. PC was in a coma from which he never recovered. And for the rest of my life I know I will be fighting a battle with grief and loneliness.
It is a little over six months since PC passed away. My mind keeps picking at the details of that last week in the hospital over and over as I lie sleepless at night, scabs on my heart that won’t quite heal. Each stark and horrifying detail is etched in my mind, including his last moments as I watched the monitor count his heart beats down to zero. The last thing I did before I left him lying there in the ICU ward was to take off his wedding band. I now wear both of them, his and mine. His band is a little loose on my finger – it makes soft clicking noises against my own wedding band as I pound away on my laptop, each keystroke underlined by a soft click reminding me he is really gone. If any part of him still exits, it is as a memory – a simulation in my brain. In any given situation, I can imagine exactly what he would say, how he would react, how he would look and sound. I can almost hear him saying “Hi Sweetie” in the special voice he reserved just for me and the gentle smile that went with it. When I am gone, this simulation in my mind will be gone too. Our two wedding bands will gather dust in companionable oblivion in my daughter’s jewelry case – a fitting end to our unconventional and sadly unfinished love story.
I have learned most people have a time limit of sorts for grief, a period of indulgence when grief is socially acceptable. Mere acquaintances feel their obligations met after a cliché or two, a nice Hallmark card in the mail, a brief and sometimes uncomfortable condolence phone call. Closer friends and family will indulge you for a while longer. But the day will come when they too drift away, anxious to get on with their own lives and erase the dank memory of death and grief – bleak reminders of their own mortality – that would otherwise darken their sunny days. We walk in a twilight zone, CLL spouses that take care of our stricken partners; some that have lost our mates to this disease, some with the sword still hanging over our heads. We straddle the sunny world of the living and twilight memories of lost loves. Our long drawn out grief fighting this “good cancer” is rarely understood, except by others who share our experience.
I expected flashes of “survivor’s guilt”. Why did he have to die and why am I still alive? I was prepared for that. But what did catch me by surprise was the number of patients who were angry. PC’s story hit home hard for a lot of people. For them, after PC’s death I became a tarnished mascot, a failed advocate. If I could not protect PC, what good am I to them? Good question to which I am afraid I have no answer. My excuse is that I never sought the responsibility of being a cancer “guru” – there are far too many of them out there already. The best I can say about myself is that I have walked in your shoes and I will continue to do so for the rest of my life. You have to decide if that is good enough for you.
Most of you I have never met. I know you only through the emails we have exchanged, sometimes a photo or two to put faces to names. Often enough, a spouse that I got to know very well would write to say goodbye, the death of the loved one precipitating unilateral decision to end our friendship as well. But for each such goodbye that I mourned there were many more hellos, new names, new stories that had uncanny resemblance to all the other stories I have listened to over the past seven years. The list of friends I have lost to CLL grows a little longer each year. There are too many addresses in my email address book that I do not have the heart to delete, anymore than I can delete the memories in my mind.
I dithered about publishing this article. Is it too personal, too mushy? But they say grief shared is grief reduced and I thought I would open this topic (can of worms?) for those of you who might find comfort in sharing your own experiences coping with loss – loss of robust good health you once took for granted, loss of unlimited time and wide open possibilities, loss of second chances to re-do and make amends, loss of time to do all the things you wanted to do and be, before CLL became a part of your daily equation. And finally, for far too many of you, loss of a special some one that was your compass, your North, South, East and West.
Be well.
Chaya (& PC)
16 comments on "Coping with Grief"
Dear Chaya,
No one expects you to be a CLL guru, just brush away those stupid, selfish, unrealistic people who aim their frustration towards you. We need you to go on, the work you do for all of us is the biggest help one can find. Your researches and rational thinking puts some order in my restless mind and soul. Since my husband was diagnosed 2 and half years ago I am fighting for both of us and now it is even harder as he is becoming depressive too. But your example is always there for me , your courage and sense of humor keep me going on , looking for the best way to help my “compass” fight his battle the best way possible.
Thank you again
Annette Driesen
There is no reason for any of your wonderful memories ever to fade. Life was never meant to be fair, only to be dealt with, and having a special relationship such as the one that you and PC shared is a special gift not granted to everyone.
Each of us walks every day with “the sword of Damocles” above our head, and if it’s not one thing, it’s another.
Early last April, when you and PC were in Minneapolis and when things seemed to be going well, I spent a few days hiking in Sedona on my way back east. On a trail I encountered an elderly man coming from the opposite direction. We chatted for awhile and I asked him if he knew PC. He told me that he did not personally know him, but that he knew of him and wished him well. PC’s memory will not fade unless we collectively allow that to happen. If you continue your quest to help people deal with their CLL, his memory will live on in all of our hearts.
Dear Chaya,
I was born and raised in my family funeral home in which we had owned since 1920. The first one for our little town. My grandma and granddaddy’s first funerals prosessions were in a wagon. I watched familys that had to come to our funeral home since 1961 when i was born. Thru the years i have found one thing that has stayed consistant when it comes to healing a broken heart after a death. My Grandma sat me down on the back porch of our funeral and told me this, to keep me strong in times of trial. She told me God gave each and every one of us somethime very special to help us thru our darkest times. She said what he gave us nobody else could ever take it away form us. She said it is the most powerful gift ever given when dealing with grief. Grandma said at first the gift didnt make much since but once it began to take a hold, it grew better and better.
The gift grandma spoke of that God gave each and every one of us is called “TIME”.
When I was 17, I had a little brother that had a very agressive brain tumor. He was 16, and we were very close. AT the end of his year and a half battle, He was so sick. With all of the surgerys and radiation, and chemo, he was not even Pat anymore, and there was no way he would ever be Pat again. He was in so much pain at the end, I prayed for god to let him die. I hated myself for years for that prayer. I blamed myself and that prayer for his death.
It has been 27 years since his death. I still dream about him occasionally, and I still miss and love him dearly. But I look back on the words of wisdom that my Grandma said that hot August afternoon. I realized that “TIME” has brought a healing to my heart, and an understanding, that i was not to blame for God’s plans for Pat. So “Time” is everything my grandma taught me it would be. I pray that “Time” will help you like it has me.
With Much Love!!
Raymond Parker
For some one who is doing a wonderful job of keeping up the hopes of so many people around them,i think you & PC deserve an applause,i hope that with time your immense grief fades away and beautiful memories of both of you reside in that place,wishin you well,take care
keep up the great work,its not you but us who need your support now.
thanks.
Chaya,
I don’t know that time makes grief less….but I do think happy feelings from treasured memories start to replace the pain of those memories more and more.
I’m glad you did decide to write of your loss from the heart. I hope it helps you a little bit to bring it out into the light. It helps me, at the same time your pain and loss hurt me, because sometimes I feel no one can imagine what the fear of losing that “world-for-two” is – they are either lucky enough to not have to think of it, or not so lucky that they don’t share that life with another.
I have always felt that the luck of having a relationship and love like you and PC comes with recognition that at some point, there is the pain of its loss. If you take the one, you take the other. But how?
In any event, I want to make just one point. Upon PC’s death, your role did not become tarnished, or failed, or less perfect. It became just the opposite – you went all the way to the front lines for and with your troops and you experienced and fought at the sharpest edge of this illness. You will be never be the same…but those of us to whom you are a vital resource, peer, friend….can never say you left any stone unturned or flagged in your personal courage. You always had the mind, the science, the analysis, the commitment the CLL community has relied on. Your experience this year has also shown that your humanity has no limits and you have been in the trenches.
For whatever reason, nothing could save PC, but if anyone could do an empirical study on the median survival of readers of CLL topics compared to all other CLL patients, I have a very strong hypothesis “Chaya” would be shown to lead to statistically signficant longer survival. The information you provide has, no doubt, led to many of us checking things sooner, choosing treatments more wisely, getting other opinions, etc.
I’ll stop there, sorry to go on so long. Your reason for living may seem a bit dimmer, but your purpose is not.
Helene
Helene:
I hope you are right about the prognostic significance of CLL Topics membership.
In a rare pensive mood weeks before he died, PC did a bit of arithmetic. We had roughly 2,500 registered members at that time. He mused that if patients lived on average just one week longer because of the information on the website, that adds up to an additional 2,500 weeks or 48 patient-years, more than double his own life expectancy if he had never been diagnosed with CLL. He thought it was a bargain worth making.
People tend to put out there, onto others, the stuff they aren’t dealing with in their own lives.
When I feel angry often it is because I am harboring fear and haven’t yet realised it. Usually fear of loss or abandonment. Anger is just an easier way of expressing it. I usually aim it randomly, at the nearest and most convenient target. My anger masks my fear, hides it from me. Sometimes it is too hard to face. To say aloud. To express. Especially if others around me are are even more afraid than I am.
Anger is a useful tool when I use it appropriately. It is an energetic emotion – lots of energy to propel action! I’ve climbed out of despair using anger – anger against feeling helpless. I get angry about CLL, the unfairness of it all. Some days when I think having CLL is my fault (thinking, I must have done, or not done, something to cause it) I get angry at CLL to stop myself sliding into depression. It’s a mean, random horrible thing and it’s hurting me and my family. In my head I angrily slash it to pieces with an imaginary sword. My anger chases the fear of CLL away. Allows me to deal with it more rationally. Gives me back my hope.
I feel like I have, by and large, a healthy relationship with my anger.
It’s sad that people experience such insecurity in their lives that they displaced their anger onto you Chaya. For every angry person there are a dozen sending your virtual hugs and counting their blessings that you and PC have come into their lives.
A couple of decades ago I realised that people live in our hearts and minds, probably more so than in the flesh. When they die, we miss their physical presence – words can’t really do justice how this feels. But they ‘live’ on, as they always did, tucked securely in our living memories. What I’ve learned is to love more now, to be ‘present’ more in each moment I spend with those I love, to celebrate these moments more, even the angry and not so happy ones. And I know that when I die, my family will hold my memory as tightly as they hold it now.
Beverley
How could anyone have shown greater love for PC than what you have shown all these years. And what you wrote and what you continue to do is the best memorial he could ever wish for. Through you, he is remembered with love by all of us.
Chaya,
In the past year, I lost my dear sister-inlaw, age 35 and another dear friend age 50 to ovarian cancer. I think about them almost daily and I know I will cont. to do so for the rest of my life. Why? I loved them. I am angry about what happened to them. They were robbed of their young lives and I was robbed too. I keep beautiful momentos of them throughout my home.
Why should I try not to do this? So I am following a formula for what others perceive as getting over grief? We each have to create our own path thru grief and loss. We should reject formulas and just do what in our hearts we find is our own path.
Sometimes I picture a gathering of all the people I have lost to the monster of cancer. There are too many people there now. I count PC among them too. The pictures you posted of him help me see him. I think they showed his true spirit, especially the one with his dog on the hiking trail. Why do I do this? Because I love them,and they deserve it.
Chris
How do we handle the loss of our guiding star? I don’t know. Tom is into his 5th year with CLL and I can now see that where once we were climbing the mountain, now we are on the other side and going down the mountain. CLL has taken it’s hold in all the new 17p/TP53 deletions, the deletion of both 13q loci. The intense side effects and problems he is having with his newest trial, Revlimid. During the crisis of these troubled waters, I work on automatic. It is almost a relief. For when I stop to meditate, the tears flow as I grieve for the man that once was. The life I once imagined we would have after 35 years of marriage. All the things I saw in my mind that we would be doing in our late 50’s, 60’s and 70’s. The sadness swells at times when we are just doing such simple things. Dinner and wine and I notice that even though we are the same age and I am laughing and full of vigor, he is fatigued and doesn’t smile as much as he used to. I grieve for the part of him that CLL has already taken. I also rejoice in the simple knowledge that for today….this one day….he is here. I can kiss him and touch him and we can share in our stories of today.
I still grieve for your loss, Chaya. I grieve because it is all of our loss. I grieve because I glimpse my future. I grieve because I will always want more time with my Star.
One thing we told our son’s was that they need not be sad for us. We told them that we rocked the World with our love for each other and that most people search a lifetime for what we shared and are still sharing after 35 years.
“I get up. I walk. I fall down. Meanwhile I keep dancing.” Hillel
I am glad that you are still dancing, Chaya.
Jenny Lou
Chaya
As Time passes your loneliness and sadness of your loss will ease. Time is an enemy and an ally. The ally in that you will start remembering more of the wonderful times that you spent together. PC was a wonderful person. The two of you were so very special & we feel blessed that we got to know both of you. We think of both of you with love & affection & mourn for PC.
Your CLL community has wrapped their arms around you to keep you filled with Love. Thank you from all of us for continuing this site to help us with our illness. We are your family and we will support you through this process. Thank you for expressing your feelings to us, and know that we are here for you.
Love,
Anne & Alan
Chaya,
I don’t think anyone who hasn’t walked in your shoes can truly know how hard it is.
But many of us have had our lives changed in ways we never wanted or expected. That’s what the CLL experience represents, of course. A fellow patient keeps a worthy quote at the top of her blog:
“We must be willing to let go of the life we have planned so as to have the life that is waiting for us.” — EM Forster
Bittersweet but wise. What else can we do?
You and PC created a world of love in those 48 patient years and by sharing your journey so publicly. Your friends may be distracted, imperfect, wrapped up in their own problems, but they are many and they are everywhere and they are here to lend love and support in that new life, the one that you didn’t want but the one that has been handed to you.
We have each other.
David
Chaya, PC will be remembered by so many people, in so many places. He lives in my mind, I remember his kind face the most. But none of this will help your own heart, and I cannot even imagine how deep the loss. Your writing captured what all of us are feeling at the loss of PC, and the loss that faces each one of us every day. My heart goes out to you each and every day. Beth
Grief can only be understood by those who have lived it. When I read your comments, I feel at home.
Dave
Dear Chaya,
You and PC had probably helped most people with CLL than you can imagine, nationally and internationally.
I first visited your site when we found out my father-in-law had it. I learned a lot and tried to share with our family all the latest info you had posted in your site. He past away 5 years ago. A couple of years after his passing a good friend of many years sent me a message telling me he had CLL so the first thing I did is referring him to your site. He is a fighter and though he went through many challenges since then, he is still there. He is on remission now but encountering some other challenges. I am very grateful to you and PC for the gargantuan job you had started, for all the hard work and effort put in your site in behalf of CLL sufferers.
I salute you and your family for being brave and keeping the good work, you are made of a very rare and wonderful fiber very hard to find nowadays.
My heart and my prayers are with you and your family.
Love,
Marta Giuliani
Hi Chaya
I look at the picture of you and PC. What a beautiful picture. You are a beautiful woman. What starts from the inside always shows even more on the outside.
I will always have wonderful memories of my husband just because we were both fortunate to have shared our lives. He gave me so much.
Midge
Leave a Comment